Latest Global Business News

US Supreme Court rules in favor of Samsung in smartphone patent suit

 
The U.S. Supreme Court sides with Samsung in its design patent battle with archrival Apple.
 
The ruling makes it less likely the Korean tech titan will have to pay the entire penalty demanded by the iPhone maker.
Hwang Hojun has the latest twist in the seemingly never-ending saga.
 
Not only have they battled for customers, but a patent dispute between the two has dragged on since 2011, a year after Samsung unveiled its Galaxy line of smartphones.
 
On Tuesday local time, the U.S. Supreme Court sided with Samsung, overturning an appeals court ruling ordering Samsung to pay 399 million dollars to its American rival for copying key iPhone designs, including its rounded corners and square icons on a touchscreen.
 
The battle began in 2011 with Apple suing Samsung for patent and trademark infringement, and a year later, the jury ruled in Apple's favor and Samsung was ordered to turn over basically all the profits it had made on 11 infringing phone models.
 
Samsung later filed a complaint, and on Tuesday it won a significant victory -- an eight-to-zero ruling by the court, which said patent infringement regarding a particular element of a design should be treated differently from the infringement of an entire design.
 
supreme court sides with samsung
 
The ruling was written by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, who wrote that a patent violator does not always have to hand over its entire profit from the sales of a product using stolen designs if the designs covered only certain components... and not the whole thing.
 
In other words, the issue is not whether Samsung violated Apple's patents, but rather how much money it's reasonable for Samsung to pay for the infringement.
 
The justices sent the case back to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit to determine what portion of its profits Samsung must pay.
 
Apple says it remains optimistic the lower courts will again send a powerful signal that intellectual property theft won't be tolerated, while Samsung says the Supreme Court's decision shows its argument was more persuasive.
 

Add comment

Emails are optional and for tracking replies. Names are unique; get yours today with a comment!


Security code
Refresh

La Business

Oil prices surge to 6-month high as U.S. announces Iran oil embargo
Oil prices surge to 6-month high as U.S. announces Iran oil embargo

  Global oil prices have hit a six-month high after skyrocketing for two consecu [ ... ]

Read more la
Men's K-beauty set for success on world stage?
Men's K-beauty set for success on world stage?

  The ‘Hallyu’, or the Korean wave continue to make big on the global stag [ ... ]

Read more la
S. Korea's top inheritance tax rate the second highest in OECD
S. Korea's top inheritance tax rate the second highest in OECD

  Inheritance tax rates vary by each country,... but South Korean heirs pay so [ ... ]

Read more la
US, China trade talks will be successful: Trump
US, China trade talks will be successful: Trump

  The U.S.-China trade dispute that rocked global financial markets in recent mo [ ... ]

Read more la
Trump renews attack against Federal Reserve, claiming it has hindered US growth
Trump renews attack against Federal Reserve, claiming it has hindered US growth

  Blaming the U.S. Federal Reserve for hindering the country's economic growth [ ... ]

Read more la
IMF official warns global economy facing various threats; downgrades forecast
IMF official warns global economy facing various threats; downgrades forecast

  The head of the IMF is warning that the global economy,... which is alread [ ... ]

Read more la
EU leaders agree to delay Brexit until October 31
EU leaders agree to delay Brexit until October 31

  EU leaders have granted an extension to Brexit, setting a new deadline of Octobe [ ... ]

Read more la
Ghosn: ‘Conspiracy at Nissan led to my arrest’
Ghosn: ‘Conspiracy at Nissan led to my arrest’

  Former Nissan Chairman Carlos Ghosn has claimed he is innocent and accused e [ ... ]

Read more la
Cryptocurrency and its future outlook
Cryptocurrency and its future outlook

  We're seeing more and more people in South Korea using services involving  [ ... ]

Read more la
Jeff Bezos remains world's richest after most expensive divorce on earth
Jeff Bezos remains world's richest after most expensive divorce on earth

  The founder of Amazon has finalized his divorce with his now ex-wife,... a [ ... ]

Read more la
US China close in on final trade agreement to end spat
US China close in on final trade agreement to end spat

  The U.S. and China are negotiating a way to end their trade spat. This ro [ ... ]

Read more la
IMF chief says global economic growth has lost momentum
IMF chief says global economic growth has lost momentum

  The head of the IMF Christine Lagarde.... is warning that global economi [ ... ]

Read more la
Market action for the week in global stocks
Market action for the week in global stocks

  29 March 2019 - It's time now for an in-depth look at the market action to [ ... ]

Read more la
Europe's first underwater restaurant opens in Norway
Europe's first underwater restaurant opens in Norway

  Europe's first underwater restaurant has opened in Norway with more than sev [ ... ]

Read more la
Samsung issues rare profit warning for Q1 2019
Samsung issues rare profit warning for Q1 2019

  Samsung Electronics has taken the rare step of announcing that it expects  [ ... ]

Read more la
China orders 300 planes from Airbus worth 34 billion
China orders 300 planes from Airbus worth 34 billion

  Chinese President Xi Jinping and French President Emmanuel Macron have signed 15 [ ... ]

Read more la

Our Sponsors


La Latest

AI Robot paints its own moonscapes in traditional Chinese style

  A Hong Kong artist has created an artificial intelligence robot which create [ ... ]

Read more la
ISIS claims responsibility for Sri Lanka Easter bombings that killed over 300

  The death toll of the terror attack in Sri Lanka on Easter Sunday cont [ ... ]

Read more la
Oil prices surge to 6-month high as U.S. announces Iran oil embargo

  Global oil prices have hit a six-month high after skyrocketing for two consecu [ ... ]

Read more la
Prince Louis celebrates his first birthday

  Prince Louis of Cambridge is celebrating his first birthday. The Prince was  [ ... ]

Read more la
High-flying daredevils battle to be World Indoor Skydiving champs

  Indoor skydivers from around the world have been showing off their synchronize [ ... ]

Read more la
Men's K-beauty set for success on world stage?

  The ‘Hallyu’, or the Korean wave continue to make big on the global stag [ ... ]

Read more la
S. Korea's top inheritance tax rate the second highest in OECD

  Inheritance tax rates vary by each country,... but South Korean heirs pay so [ ... ]

Read more la
Noah's Ark: Bolivian artists celebrate Easter with elaborate sand sculptures

  Bolivia has been celebrating Easter by carving out series of enormous sand scu [ ... ]

Read more la

La Entertain

Andy Yang Zi secretly looking for boyfriends online?

On 24 April 2019, fans of Andy Yang Zi (26) - yes, that's right, this lady's English name is Andy Ya [ ... ]

Read more la
Avengers: Endgame hits record 2 million advance cinema ticket sales

  There's unprecedented interest in South Korea about the new Avengers film. [ ... ]

Read more la
Song Hyekyo shares naked arms & legs in new sexy photoshoot

On 22 April 2019, South Korean darling Song Hyekyo shares with us her latest sexy photoshoot, baring [ ... ]

Read more la
Joe Chen QiaoEn & mv boyfriend Hu Xia celebrate her birthday; Wang Kai missing in action

Recently, Taiwanese actress Joe Chen QiaoEn, celebrated her big Four Zero - 40 - birthday around 4 A [ ... ]

Read more la
BTS' new video sets 3 Guinness World Records

  K-pop stars BTS have made music video history after the video for their so [ ... ]

Read more la
Kris Wu sings to mother at Nanjing Alive Tour; girlfriend Guli Nazha on mc

On 20 April 2019 Saturday night, Kris Wu was holding his concert in Nanjing and charmed his fans wit [ ... ]

Read more la
Lynn Hung's twin daughters celebrate birthdays, Kaylor & Lyvia Kwok, not with ex-boyfriend Aaron Kwok

On 19 April 2019, Lynn Hung (38, Xiong Dailin) shares photos of her twin daughters celebrating their [ ... ]

Read more la
Eric Moo's daughter Yonghuan inherits sexy hour glass figure from wife Peng Mei Jun

On 19 April 2019, Malaysian-Chinese singer Eric Moo (Wu Qixian, 56) shares close-up and slightly sex [ ... ]

Read more la