Latest Singapore News

Circle Line breakdowns likely caused by train carriage 46's signalling faults

After several weeks of investigations, a joint team (we) comprising the Land Transport Authority (LTA), SMRT, the signalling system manufacturer Alstom, the Infocomm Media Development Authority (IMDA), the Defence Science & Technology Agency (DSTA), DSO National Laboratories, the Government Technology Agency of Singapore (GovTech) and electro-magnetic interference specialist Rohde & Schwarz, has traced the source of the signalling problems on the Circle Line (CCL) to an intermittent failure of the signalling hardware on one train, Passenger Vehicle 46 (PV46).
 
The loss of communications on the trains close to PV46 and its intermittent signalling failures resulted in their emergency brakes being automatically activated, as a safety feature. Ongoing investigations indicate a strong likelihood that intermittent hardware failure on PV46 was also the cause for the about 200 occurrences of loss of signalling communications on CCL trains between 28 August and 2 September 2016.
 
circle line breakdown caused by faulty carriage pic1
 
Investigation Findings
 
An initial hypothesis was that interference from telecommunications signals may have caused the repeated activation of the trains’ emergency brakes. To test this, LTA, together with IMDA and the mobile network operators, suspended mobile telecom services across the entire CCL for two hours in the evening of 3 November 2016, and then for a full day on 4 November 2016. These tests showed that telecommunications signals were not the source of the interference.
 
Meanwhile, engineers and data scientists from DSTA and GovTech studied data collected from train logs and incident reports, and found that almost all of the faults occurred in the proximity of one particular train, PV46. On Sunday, 6 November 2016, we tested if PV46 was the source of the problem by running the train during revenue hours.
 
We found that PV46 indeed caused a loss of communications between nearby trains and the trackside signalling system, resulting in the activation of emergency brakes on these trains. Before PV46 was put into service on that day, no loss of communications was observed on any CCL train.   
 
Further tests on PV46 by engineers from LTA, DSTA and Rohde & Schwarz showed that faulty train signalling hardware on PV46 was emitting erroneous signals in addition to the ones it was supposed to emit. These erroneous signals occasionally prevented trains travelling in the vicinity of PV46, including in the opposite direction, from properly communicating with the trackside signalling system. This loss of communications led to the activation of the trains’ emergency brakes.
 
PV46 has been deployed for service since July 2015. Before being put into service, the train was tested extensively both at the manufacturing location as well as under local conditions. It is unclear at this point why the train’s signalling hardware has been experiencing intermittent failure. So far, no other train has been found to have the same hardware issue, but we continue to monitor the situation closely.
 
PV46 has been pulled out of service while LTA and SMRT continue to work with Alstom on further investigations and rectification of its faulty hardware. LTA and SMRT will also conduct a thorough examination of the signalling hardware for the rest of the CCL fleet.
 
Mr Chew Men Leong, Chief Executive (LTA), said, “Following our earlier assessment that the signalling faults on the Circle Line were caused by an interfering signal, the joint team spent many weeks trying to trace the source. The sporadic occurrence of the incidents at different points along the Circle Line made it challenging for the investigators and I thank commuters for their patience during this period.
 
I am also grateful for the collaboration with the other Government agencies and the cooperation from the telcos in helping us nail down the problem. In particular, I thank the engineers and data scientists from DSTA and GovTech respectively, without whom we would not have been able to theorise the possibility of a faulty train, and identify PV46.”
 
Credits: LTA, SMRT
 

Add comment

Emails are optional and for tracking replies. Names are unique; get yours today with a comment!

Security code
Refresh

La Daily

S. Korean container ship attacked by pirates Monday near Singapore Strait
S. Korean container ship attacked by pirates Monday near Singapore Strait

  A container ship under the South Korean flag has been attacked by pirates t [ ... ]

Read more la
'Shangri-La Dialogue 2019' kicks off in Singapore this Friday
'Shangri-La Dialogue 2019' kicks off in Singapore this Friday

  Top defense officials from various nations have gathered in Singapore fo [ ... ]

Read more la
Multinational maritime drills held in Busan, Singapore starting Monday
Multinational maritime drills held in Busan, Singapore starting Monday

  Multinational maritime drills are being held in waters near Korea's southern [ ... ]

Read more la
SimplyGo: Taking the MRT requires no Top-Ups anymore
SimplyGo: Taking the MRT requires no Top-Ups anymore

Use Your Mastercard® Contactless Bank Cards for Public Transport, with No Need for Top-Ups. The Lan [ ... ]

Read more la
Singapore Hong Kong Paris most expensive cities in the world
Singapore Hong Kong Paris most expensive cities in the world

  March 2019 - A new report shows Seoul is tied with New York City when it comes [ ... ]

Read more la
HDB BTO Balloting Time reduced from 6 weeks to 3 weeks from May 2019
HDB BTO Balloting Time reduced from 6 weeks to 3 weeks from May 2019

At the Committee of Supply debate today, the Ministry for National Development announced measures to [ ... ]

Read more la
HIV registry data leak not result of hack-in by advanced persistent threat actors
HIV registry data leak not result of hack-in by advanced persistent threat actors

Following an alert by the Police, the Ministry of Health (MOH) has ascertained that confidential inf [ ... ]

Read more la
Sexiest Air Stewardess in Asia not from SIA?
Sexiest Air Stewardess in Asia not from SIA?

Mabel Goo has been voted as the sexiest air stewardess in Asia according to an informal online poll  [ ... ]

Read more la
Orchard Road turns No Smoking Zone from 1 Jan 2019
Orchard Road turns No Smoking Zone from 1 Jan 2019

More than 40 Designated Smoking Areas available within the Orchard Road No Smoking Zone. Advisory ap [ ... ]

Read more la
First South Korean President to visit Singapore in 20 years
First South Korean President to visit Singapore in 20 years

  South Korean President Moon Jae-in kicked off his first full day in Singapor [ ... ]

Read more la
Muslims across the world celebrate the end of Ramadan
Muslims across the world celebrate the end of Ramadan

  Muslims across the world have gathered together to celebrate the end of Rama [ ... ]

Read more la
Kim-Trump summit day finally arrives
Kim-Trump summit day finally arrives

  Thanks for joining us on our special coverage of the historic summit between [ ... ]

Read more la
President Trump at Shangri-La; Kim Jong-un at St Regis? TrumpKim Summit 2018
President Trump at Shangri-La; Kim Jong-un at St Regis? TrumpKim Summit 2018

  With the venue for the historic summit confirmed as the Capella Hotel on Singa [ ... ]

Read more la
Trump-Kim Summit 2018 set at Capella Hotel, Sentosa
Trump-Kim Summit 2018 set at Capella Hotel, Sentosa

  US President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un will meet at a [ ... ]

Read more la

Our Sponsors


La Latest

Twin panda cubs born in Berlin

  Two panda cubs weighing 186g and 136g were born at Zoo Berlin on Saturday ev [ ... ]

Read more la
Typhoon Lingling to slam S. Korea this weekend

Be sure to have an umbrella handy this week,... because the autumn monsoon season is [ ... ]

Read more la
Tens of thousands protest over plans to suspend Parliament

  Tens of thousands of people protest against Boris Johnson's plans to suspe [ ... ]

Read more la
Indonesia to move capital city to eastern Borneo, replacing Jakarta

  Indonesia has announced that it's moving its capital from the crowded megaci [ ... ]

Read more la
U.S. yield curve inverts further, pointing to possible recession ahead

The gap between the two-year and 30-year U.S. Treasury yields, a closely-followe [ ... ]

Read more la
Massive wildfires in Amazon rainforest emerging as "global crisis"

  Flames are spreading across the Amazon rainforest this summer, spewing m [ ... ]

Read more la
Disney's video streaming service to debut in November for US$6.99 a month

  The Walt Disney Corporation announced Monday that it will launch its Disney- [ ... ]

Read more la
Brazil sends in army to tackle Amazon rainforest fires

  Brazil's army will launch a one-month operation from Saturday to tackle the  [ ... ]

Read more la

La Entertain

Beauty queen Whitney Hui married to Alexander in stylish wedding; boyfriend turns husband

3 Sep 2019 - Actress and Miss Hong Kong second runner-up Whitney Hui (30) finally married her foreig [ ... ]

Read more la
Angelababy lunches with David Beckham - Fish & Chips style

3 Sep 2019 - Angelababy was filming with David Beckham in Macau and Beckham graciously prepared an a [ ... ]

Read more la
Kris Wu holds girlfriend Luyi Luna's hands in carpark; wipes student's wet...

31 Aug 2019 - Kris Wuyi Fan (28) has been spotted holding the hands of his girlfriend Luyi Luna (19) [ ... ]

Read more la
Elva Hsiao's new underaged boyfriend Justin Huang Hao

27 Aug 2019 - Over the last weekend, Elva Hsiao (40) decided to go public with her new boyfriend num [ ... ]

Read more la
Wang Leehom's wife Lee Jinglei celebrates son Wang Jiayao's 1st birthday

24 Aug 2019 - Wang Leehom (43)'s wife Lee Jinglei (33, also Li Jinglei) delivered a baby son Wang Ji [ ... ]

Read more la
Zhao Liying first day at work after delivering baby son for husband William Feng Shaofeng

22 Aug 2019 - Zhao Liying Zanilia has been spotted on a number of occasions after her pregnancy but  [ ... ]

Read more la
Tiffany Tang's baby daughter bump too big to hide

22 Aug 2019 - On a recent filming session while Tiffany Tang was on the set, she was dressed in bagg [ ... ]

Read more la
Donnie Yen & Takuya Kimura's daughters grow up; Jasmine Yen & Mitsuki Kimura

Japanese heartthrob Takuya Kimura (46)'s 16 year old daughter Mitsuki Kimura has just made her debut [ ... ]

Read more la